You can never go wrong with a warm-toned eyeshadow like this one. Boasting a mix of high-pigment mattes and shimmers, this palette has everything you need to create an eye look with just one product.

Whether you enjoy an intricate wing, a touch of sparkle, or a beginner-friendly one-and-done formula, finding a cream eyeshadow for mature eyes that won't cake, crease, or smudge throughout the day is ...